Vitalik Buterin Challenges Ethereum's Ultrasound Money Idea - Cointribune

Vitalik Buterin Challenges Ethereum's Ultrasound Money Idea - Cointribune

Vitalik Buterin Challenges Ethereum's Ultrasound Money Idea

Vitalik Buterin no longer wants the value of ETH to depend mainly on the fees burned by Ethereum. His reasoning resolves a contradiction that has become central: the network cannot simultaneously make its transactions cheaper and rely on high fees to support the token’s scarcity.

In Brief

  • Vitalik Buterin believes that the value of ETH should no longer depend mainly on the fees burned on Ethereum.
  • He favors a vision of ETH as a store of value, based on the security and resilience of the network.
  • The decrease in transaction fees and the rise of layer 2 solutions significantly reduce ETH burn.
  • According to Buterin, maintaining high fees to make ETH rarer would penalize users and slow Ethereum adoption.
  • The long-term value of ETH should rely more on trust, decentralization, and the network’s ability to withstand crises.

Ethereum Abandons Making Fees Its Main Argument

Since the introduction of EIP-1559 in 2021, a portion of the fees paid on Ethereum is permanently burned. This mechanism fueled the thesis of “the ultrasound money”. When burns exceed the emissions paid to validators, the supply of ETH decreases.

Vitalik Buterin now believes this mechanism should no longer be the core of the token’s valuation. He summarizes his position: “ETH as a store of value makes much more sense than ETH considered as an asset whose value depends on burned fees.”

His argument is based on several observations:

  • The burn peaks mainly came from speculative activities internal to crypto.
  • These revenues would have decreased alongside the price of ETH during a crisis.
  • Layer 2 networks sustainably reduce the fees paid on the main chain.
  • Maximizing burn would incentivize Ethereum to maintain costly transactions.

Buterin does not propose removing EIP-1559. “We should keep it,” he specifies, adding that holders should not worry if burns remain sustainably below 10% of the level necessary to offset new emissions.

The evolution is already visible. Ethereum burned about 1.48 million ETH in 2022, compared to only 19,200 ETH since the beginning of 2026 at the time of the source article’s publication. This drop notably reflects the shift of some activity to less costly layer 2 solutions.

High Fees Would Eventually Penalize Ethereum

The new doctrine defended by Buterin breaks the artificial link between the interests of users and those of ETH holders. If the token’s value depends primarily on burned fees, every decrease in transaction costs becomes negative for investors, even when it improves the network experience.

Conversely, seeking more burn would mean encouraging high fees. Such a strategy could exclude individuals as well as users who most need private and censorship-resistant transactions.

Buterin also contests the idea that burns would create a true valuation floor. He cites the theoretical example of a token burning one billion dollars per year: with a 4% discount rate, this income could justify a 25 billion dollar market cap. But this calculation only works if revenues remain stable when the market falls.

However, much of the record fees recorded between 2021 and 2023 came from NFTs and speculation. The sale of Otherdeed virtual lands alone caused approximately $180 million of burns in one day. The NFTs involved now trade far below their initial level, illustrating the unstable nature of this revenue source.

Turning Ethereum into a fee machine would also require more interventionist governance. Buterin estimates a network run like a large company would need to massively fund its development. He mentions about 700,000 ETH in annual protocol-integrated expenses, which could reduce validators’ revenues by two-thirds.

The Value of ETH Would Depend First on Its Ability to Survive

The new narrative proposed by Buterin relies less on mechanical scarcity and more on infrastructure strength. According to him, the first quality of a store of value is its ability to withstand crises. The long-term value of ETH should be based on trust, decentralization, and the network’s ability to withstand crises, rather than on the artificial scarcity created by burning fees.

Leave a Reply