Illustration: Ethereum Diamond
Ethereum's debate on issuing new ether to validators takes center stage at Devcon 8 in Mumbai on Wednesday. A roundtable discussion scheduled for 08:00–08:55 UTC (1:30–2:25 p.m. India time) will explore the EIP-8363 proposal, but it is not a vote on a network upgrade.
Key Takeaways
- Roundtable Focus: Devcon's November 4 roundtable will discuss EIP-8363; it aims to clarify the proposal's trade-offs.
- Technical Calculation: TECHi's calculation shows that the idealized consensus-duty reward would match current levels at approximately 38.0 million active ETH.
- Current Active ETH: As of 00:09 UTC Wednesday, there are 44.31 million ETH active.
- Reward Alignment: The draft proposal's temporary reward boost would result in net duty rewards being about 26% below the existing schedule.
- Process-Centric Approach: The authors propose a structured process involving Devcon discussions, workshops, and a final forum at EthCC in April to decide on the proposal.
Process Outline:
- Devcon Forum: Identify objectives and objections.
- Workshops: Further modeling and discussion.
- Tentative January Forum: Aim to converge on a feasible draft.
- EthCC Forum (April): Engage core developers and consider inclusion.
Forecasting Scenarios:
- Debate and Modeling: The next few months will likely involve more debate and simulations under the current issuance rules.
- Design Revision: A revised EIP could emerge, or the process might conclude that a change is not justified.
- No Immediate Burn: None of these paths leads to an immediate reduction in validator rewards.
The authors' primary concern is the potential for a permanent yield floor, which could continue attracting ETH to staking products even as the security benefits diminish. Opponents and operators have raised questions regarding the impact on solo validators and the composition of the validator set. A successful outcome from today's session could provide clarity on these matters.