Manhattan court acquits Peraire-Bueno brothers in Ethereum MEV fraud case - Traders Union

Manhattan Court Acquits Peraire-Bueno Brothers in Ethereum MEV Fraud Case

A U.S. court ruling narrows how prosecutors can apply wire fraud statutes to trading strategies on decentralized blockchain networks. The decision clears Anton and James Peraire-Bueno in a case tied to a 2023 Ethereum exploit that caused MEV bots to lose more than $25 million in seconds.

Highlights

  • A Manhattan federal judge acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers of wire fraud after ruling their Ethereum MEV trading conduct did not meet the legal definition of criminal fraud.
  • The April 2023 incident involved MEV bots losing over $25 million due to manipulated transactions on the Ethereum blockchain, leading to the brothers' arrest in May 2024 and an eventual mistrial in November 2025.
  • The ruling may set a precedent limiting how U.S. authorities prosecute crypto market manipulation cases involving public blockchains rather than regulated financial venues.

Court Ruling on Ethereum Trading Conduct

As reported by The Block, a Manhattan federal judge acquitted the MIT-educated brothers of wire fraud and related charges after finding that the conduct described by prosecutors did not amount to criminal fraud under the cited statutes.

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke stated that the key issue was not whether the strategy was improper or unethical, but whether it legally constituted wire fraud. The ruling stated that prosecutors did not show that the brothers made material misrepresentations in carrying out the scheme, and it granted their motion for acquittal.

The case centered on bait transactions used to manipulate sandwich bots before the brothers intercepted trades. The judge noted that these transactions did not occur on a regulated market where the alleged conduct would have been prohibited under the theory advanced by prosecutors.

Crypto Market and Enforcement Implications

The underlying incident occurred in April 2023, when a group of MEV bots lost more than $25 million during a sophisticated attack on the Ethereum blockchain. The attacker replaced normal MEV transactions with malicious ones, causing the bots to execute losing trades within seconds.

Prosecutors arrested the Peraire-Bueno brothers in May 2024, arguing that they exploited the Ethereum blockchain through maximal extractable value (MEV), a term used for the maximum value that can be extracted from a DeFi protocol or smart contract by a user or group of users. The prosecution effort later stalled, and a mistrial was declared in November 2025 after a jury deadlocked in Manhattan federal court.

The ruling may influence how U.S. authorities pursue future crypto market manipulation cases, especially where conduct occurs through public blockchain transactions rather than on regulated venues. Coin Center executive director Peter Van Valkenburgh previously characterized the case as a "massive overstep," stating that jurors without crypto expertise were likely to find the facts difficult to grasp.

Leave a Reply